Retirement income
Annuities: When Do They Make Sense?
If you are a disciplined saver and a good investor, you may wonder why you would ever need an annuity. After all, you can manage your own investments.
The answer is that an annuity isn’t necessarily about getting better investment returns. It is about transferring certain risks to an insurance company.
What Risk Does an Annuity Solve?
The biggest is longevity risk—the possibility of outliving your money.
A lifetime annuity can provide a predictable income stream for life, regardless of how long you live. This can complement Social Security, pensions, and investment income.
But there is another important consideration: financial continuity.
What If You Can No Longer Manage the Finances?
In many families, one spouse handles most of the financial planning, investments, taxes, insurance, and retirement decisions.
What happens if that person becomes seriously ill, experiences cognitive decline, or dies?
The surviving spouse or children may suddenly have to manage a complicated financial system they don’t understand.
An annuity can simplify one part of that problem by creating a predictable income stream that doesn’t require ongoing investment decisions.
It doesn’t replace a financial continuity plan, but it can make the plan easier to manage. See Financial Continuity: Making Sure Your Family Can Continue the Plan.
When Might an Annuity Make Sense?
An annuity may be worth considering when you want to:
- Create guaranteed lifetime income
- Reduce the risk of outliving your assets
- Reduce reliance on portfolio withdrawals
- Protect against poor markets early in retirement
- Simplify finances for a spouse or future caregiver
- Reduce the financial-management burden later in life
- Provide income beginning at an advanced age
A deferred income annuity can be particularly useful as longevity insurance, providing income later in life when the risk of living well beyond average life expectancy becomes more significant.
Annuities Have Tradeoffs
Annuities are not automatically good investments. Depending on the product, they may involve:
- Limited liquidity
- Fees and surrender charges
- Inflation risk
- Insurance-company credit risk
- Limited investment upside
- Reduced assets available to heirs
- Complex contract provisions
Therefore, an annuity should solve a clearly identified problem—not simply be purchased because someone recommends one.
The Better Question
Instead of asking:
Should I buy an annuity?
ask:
Which financial risks do I want to manage myself, and which am I willing to transfer?
Investments can provide growth, flexibility, and legacy wealth. Annuities can provide income certainty and longevity protection.
And a strong retirement plan should consider one additional question:
If the person managing the finances can no longer do it, will the plan still work?
The best financial plan isn’t necessarily the one with the highest projected return. It is the one that continues to provide security, simplicity, and continuity throughout the family’s lifetime.
Read more
Using Annuities as Part of a Retirement and Family Continuity Plan
Annuities are often presented as either a great retirement solution or something investors should avoid. The reality is more nuanced.
For a financially disciplined household, an annuity can be useful when it solves a specific problem that the investment portfolio cannot solve as effectively.
Start With the Risks
A retirement plan needs to address more than investment returns. Consider five risks:
Your investments decline.
You live much longer than expected.
You need to sell investments during unfavorable markets.
The person managing the finances can no longer do so.
A spouse or children inherit the finances without understanding how the plan works.
An annuity can potentially address some of the first three and, indirectly, help with the last two.
The “Financial Manager” Problem
Many families have one person who manages most of the finances. That person may know where every account is located, how investments are allocated, how much can safely be withdrawn, when taxes and Roth conversions should occur, which insurance policies are in place, and how the estate plan is structured.
This works well while that person is capable of managing everything.
But illness, cognitive decline, incapacity, or death can suddenly transfer that responsibility to someone who may not be prepared.
A retirement plan should therefore answer:
Can someone else successfully operate this plan if I can’t?
Where an Annuity Can Help
A lifetime income annuity can turn part of a complex retirement strategy into something relatively simple: a guaranteed payment arrives every month.
That income can be combined with Social Security and pensions to cover some essential expenses.
The investment portfolio can then be used for discretionary spending, emergencies, inflation protection, growth, travel and lifestyle, and legacy planning.
This separation can make the overall plan easier for a surviving spouse or successor to understand and manage.
You Don’t Have to Annuitize Everything
One of the biggest misconceptions is that choosing an annuity means putting the majority of your retirement assets into one. It doesn’t.
A household might instead use a partial annuitization strategy. For example:
Social Security + pension + modest annuity
Growth and flexibility
Assets specifically positioned for heirs
This can provide a balance between certainty, flexibility, and inheritance.
Consider “Longevity Insurance”
A particularly interesting strategy is an annuity that begins paying much later in life.
Instead of using a large amount of money to generate income immediately, a portion of the assets can be dedicated to providing income beginning at an advanced age.
The objective is simple:
If you live a very long life, part of your future income is guaranteed.
This can allow the rest of the portfolio to be managed with greater flexibility.
But Don’t Ignore the Tradeoffs
The guarantees come at a price.
Depending on the product, you may give up some combination of liquidity, investment upside, access to principal, inflation protection, and estate value.
There may also be fees, surrender provisions, and insurer credit risk.
Different annuities can have dramatically different structures, so the word “annuity” alone tells you very little about whether a particular product is appropriate.
A Better Way to Evaluate an Annuity
Before considering a specific product, identify the job you want it to perform. Ask:
- How much of our essential expenses are already covered by Social Security and pensions?
- How much guaranteed lifetime income do we actually need?
- How much portfolio risk are we comfortable retaining?
- Would guaranteed income make the portfolio easier for the surviving spouse to manage?
- What happens to the money if we die early?
- How important is leaving these assets to our children?
- How much liquidity do we need?
- Who will manage our finances if neither spouse can?
Only after answering these questions should you evaluate a particular annuity.
The Bigger Picture
Annuities should not be viewed in isolation. They are one component of a broader financial architecture that can include:
Social Security → Pension → Annuity → Investments → Insurance → Estate plan → Family continuity plan
Each component has a different job.
The objective isn’t to find the product with the highest return.
It is to build a system that continues to work through retirement, market volatility, longevity, incapacity, and eventually the transfer of wealth to the next generation.
The Final Test
A useful retirement plan should pass this test:
If the person who designed and managed the family’s finances suddenly couldn’t do it, would the family still know what to do—and would the plan still work?
If the answer is no, the solution may not necessarily be an annuity.
It may be better documentation, education, simplified investments, professional assistance, appropriate legal authority—or some combination of all of them.
An annuity is simply one potential tool for making the financial plan more resilient, predictable, and easier to continue.
This article is for education and discussion—not financial, tax, legal, or insurance advice, and not a recommendation to buy, keep, or surrender any annuity. Annuity contracts, guarantees, and fees vary by product and insurer. Guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing company. Coordinate with licensed professionals. Su Bella Vida is not an insurer, broker, or registered investment advisor. Read our terms & disclaimer.